Stablecoins are emerging as an alternative to traditional cross-border payment infrastructure, but new research suggests that blockchain technology alone will not make international transfers cheaper or more efficient.
A working paper published by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) on October 19, 2026, compares three ways to move money across borders: traditional bank wires, fintech money-transfer operators, and stablecoin-based transfers. The researchers find that stablecoins can offer advantages in certain markets, but conversion costs, limited liquidity, and dependence on intermediaries remain significant barriers.
The findings arrive as another study from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) highlights the potential competitive impact on established payment providers. Published in March 2026, the IMF paper estimates that US legislation supporting payment stablecoins could reduce the market value of listed incumbent payment firms by approximately $300 billion, or 18%, based on its market-event analysis and extrapolation method. That estimate reflects investor expectations, not a confirmed loss of cash or revenue.
Together, the studies offer a more nuanced picture of the stablecoin opportunity. These digital assets could challenge existing payment networks, especially in cross-border transfers. However, their long-term competitiveness will depend on market depth, access to local currencies, regulatory compliance, and confidence in the intermediaries that connect blockchain networks to the traditional financial system.
BIS Research Compares Banks, Fintechs, and Stablecoins
The BIS working paper, Competing Rails for Cross-Border Payments: Banks, Fintechs, and Stablecoins, was written by Wenxin Du, Catherine Huang, and David Scharfstein.
The researchers compare payment costs across different transfer sizes and currency corridors. Their analysis combines bank wire transactions, intraday pricing from fintech money-transfer operators, World Bank remittance data, and cryptocurrency market data.
Importantly, the paper looks beyond blockchain transaction fees. It considers foreign-exchange markups, exchange trading charges, conversion costs, and fiat withdrawal fees to estimate the overall cost of moving money internationally.
That distinction matters because a stablecoin transfer can be cheap on-chain while the complete payment remains expensive. A sender may need to convert local currency into a digital token, transfer it across a blockchain, and then convert it back into the recipient's currency.
Each stage can introduce costs, operational delays, and reliance on service providers.
The BIS researchers conclude that fintech money-transfer operators have already reduced cross-border payment costs substantially compared with traditional retail bank wires. They also find that stablecoins are not a universal solution to the frictions affecting international payments.
Why Stablecoins Challenge Traditional Cross-Border Payments
Traditional international payments often depend on correspondent banking relationships. Banks use these arrangements to transfer funds between institutions operating in different countries and currencies. SWIFT messaging can support the communication of payment instructions, although it is not itself a settlement system.
This infrastructure serves an important role in global commerce. However, cross-border transfers can involve multiple institutions, foreign exchange conversion, compliance checks, and fees.
Stablecoins offer a different payment structure. These digital tokens aim to maintain a stable value relative to an underlying currency, commonly the US dollar. Depending on the arrangement, users can transfer tokens across blockchain networks without sending every transaction through the same correspondent banking chain.
The BIS paper examines how networks such as Ethereum, Solana, and Tron support these transfers. It also considers the economics of converting between traditional currencies and stablecoins.
One model, often called the “stablecoin sandwich,” involves three stages:
- The sender converts local currency into a stablecoin.
- The stablecoin moves across a blockchain network.
- The recipient or a service provider converts the token into local currency.
This model can reduce dependence on some traditional payment intermediaries. Yet it does not eliminate intermediaries altogether. Crypto exchanges, liquidity providers, and fiat on- and off-ramp services can still play essential roles.
The competitive question is therefore not simply whether blockchain transactions are faster or cheaper. It is whether the complete payment journey offers a better combination of cost, speed, reliability, and accessibility.
The Hidden Costs Behind Cheap Blockchain Transfers
One of the most important findings in the BIS research is that the total cost of stablecoin transfers can extend well beyond network fees.
Blockchain fees may be negligible relative to the amount transferred. However, users can still face exchange commissions, currency conversion spreads, withdrawal charges, and other service fees.
Recipients may also need to wait for stablecoin conversion and bank processing before funds become available in their bank accounts.
These costs can vary by currency corridor, transfer size, and the liquidity available in the relevant markets. As a result, a payment route that works well for one currency pair may not offer the same advantages for another.
The comparison also highlights the progress made by fintech money-transfer operators. In the BIS researchers' small sample of traditional bank transactions, foreign-exchange markups ranged from approximately 2% to 4.7%, before explicit wire fees.
By contrast, fintech transfer costs were considerably lower in the study. For US transfers of $10,000 across developed-market currency groups, median costs were around $40 to $60, although some destinations remained more expensive.
This is an important qualification to the stablecoin narrative. Fintechs have already put pressure on traditional payment costs through digital onboarding, transparent pricing, and more efficient transfer models.
Stablecoin providers must therefore compete not only with legacy banks but also with established digital money-transfer services that have already improved the customer experience.
Liquidity Is a Major Constraint for Stablecoin FX
A payment rail needs more than inexpensive transactions. It also needs sufficient liquidity to exchange currencies at predictable prices, especially when transfers become large.
The supplied report highlights a substantial gap between dollar-stablecoin/euro trading and the broader euro foreign-exchange market. It cites estimated daily trading of approximately $200 million for dollar stablecoins against the euro across centralized and decentralized exchanges, compared with roughly $2.7 trillion in daily foreign-exchange turnover involving the euro.
These figures illustrate the difference in scale between stablecoin currency markets and established foreign-exchange markets. They should not be interpreted as perfectly comparable measures of payment activity: FX turnover includes a broad range of instruments and transactions, while stablecoin trading data covers a different market segment.
Still, limited market depth can matter when businesses need to move large amounts. Thin liquidity may increase price impact, widen spreads, or make it harder to convert funds at a predictable rate.
That creates a challenge for corporate treasury teams, remittance providers, and payment companies considering stablecoins for higher-value transfers.
A network may settle a token transfer quickly, but the business still needs a reliable way to exchange that token into the currency its supplier or customer actually uses.
The BIS researchers conclude that limited liquidity and volatile pricing constrain the scale of some stablecoin-based transfers. They also note that favorable exchange rates in certain emerging markets can reflect capital controls and market distortions rather than a technological advantage in the payment rail itself.
Where Stablecoins Could Offer an Advantage
The research does not suggest that stablecoins lack potential. Instead, it points to specific conditions in which they may be useful.
Emerging markets can have fragmented foreign-exchange markets, restrictions on capital movement, and differences between official exchange rates and prices available through alternative channels. In such circumstances, stablecoin-based transfers may offer access to different liquidity pools or more favorable pricing.
The researchers caution, however, that such advantages need careful interpretation. A difference between official and alternative exchange rates may reflect market distortions or capital controls, not necessarily greater efficiency from blockchain technology.
Stablecoins may also appeal to users who need to transfer value across borders outside conventional banking hours or who have access to digital wallets but limited access to international banking services.
Yet the outcome depends on the full payment process. Users need a trusted way to acquire tokens, transfer them, comply with applicable rules, and convert them into spendable local currency.
For businesses, the assessment must also account for accounting treatment, operational controls, counterparty exposure, and the legal status of the services involved.
The opportunity is therefore corridor-specific rather than universal. A stablecoin model that works for a particular remittance route may not be suitable for every corporate payment or currency pair.
IMF Estimates a $300 Billion Market-Value Impact on Payment Firms
The BIS paper examines the economics of different payment rails. A separate IMF study considers how financial markets view the competitive threat posed by stablecoins.
The IMF working paper, Stablecoins and the Future of Payments: Evidence from Financial Markets, was published on March 20, 2026, by Alexander Copestake, Cage Englander, Maria Soledad Martinez Peria and Germán Villegas-Bauer.
The researchers studied stock-market reactions around key congressional votes on the GENIUS Act, US legislation establishing a regulatory framework for payment stablecoins. The law was intended to reduce regulatory uncertainty and establish requirements for designated payment stablecoins.
The researchers found that listed incumbent payment firms experienced a negative market reaction relative to other financial firms around a decisive legislative vote. They then combined their event-study findings with prediction-market data to estimate the broader expected impact of the legislation.
Their resulting estimate suggests an approximately 18% reduction in the market value of incumbent payment firms, equivalent to about $300 billion. The paper reports a sensitivity range of roughly $220 billion to $470 billion under alternative assumptions.
The figure requires careful interpretation. It is an econometric estimate of how investors may have repriced established payment companies in response to legislation expected to support stablecoin adoption. It is not evidence that stablecoins have already taken $300 billion in revenue from payment firms.
The authors also identify differences between companies. Firms focused on cross-border payments faced a larger estimated impact, while firms with strong network effects or existing crypto-related services experienced a smaller effect.
That pattern suggests investors may see the greatest competitive exposure among companies whose businesses rely heavily on cross-border payment services and who have fewer protections or less existing involvement in digital assets.
What the Research Means for Banks and Fintechs
The two studies highlight different parts of the same shift.
For traditional banks, stablecoins could challenge aspects of correspondent banking by providing an alternative method to move tokenised value across borders. However, banks retain advantages in regulated customer relationships, access to deposit accounts, compliance infrastructure and established foreign-exchange services.
For fintech money-transfer operators, the competitive challenge may be more immediate. These firms have already reduced costs in many corridors, so stablecoin providers need to show that their end-to-end services can compete on price, reliability and access to local currency.
For payment networks, the IMF findings suggest that investors may be reassessing how stablecoins could affect future cash flows. That does not mean every payment network will lose market share. Established networks may have customer relationships, acceptance infrastructure and network effects that are difficult to reproduce.
For stablecoin issuers and infrastructure providers, the BIS research highlights the importance of liquidity, conversion partners and reliable fiat access. Token issuance and blockchain settlement are only parts of a complete payment service.
Finally, regulators face a broader question: how to support payment innovation while addressing risks around reserves, redemption, illicit finance, consumer protection and operational resilience.
The outcome will likely depend on how these systems integrate with existing financial infrastructure, rather than whether one technology completely replaces another.
Stablecoins May Reshape Payment Rails Rather Than Replace Them
The BIS and IMF studies offer complementary perspectives on stablecoin competition.
The BIS research shows that stablecoin transfers can bypass parts of traditional cross-border infrastructure, but the complete payment still depends on currency conversion, market liquidity and intermediaries. It also finds that fintech money-transfer operators already deliver significant cost advantages over traditional retail bank wires.
The IMF research, meanwhile, suggests that investors view stablecoins as a potentially meaningful competitive force for established payment firms, particularly those focused on cross-border transactions.
Neither finding proves that stablecoins will replace banks, fintechs or payment networks. Instead, they show that the competitive landscape is changing and that the economics will differ across payment corridors and business models.
For TheFinRate audience, the key issue is the complete payment journey. Lower blockchain fees matter, but so do exchange spreads, liquidity, local currency access, compliance and customer confidence.
TheFinRate Takeaway: Stablecoins are becoming a serious contender in cross-border payments, but the strongest model will not necessarily be the one with the cheapest blockchain transaction. It will be the one that delivers competitive end-to-end costs, dependable liquidity and trusted access to local currencies. The BIS findings challenge the idea that stablecoins automatically solve cross-border payment friction, while the IMF estimate signals that investors are already taking the competitive threat seriously.
BIS Paper Finds Stablecoins Compete With Cross-Border Banking Infrastructure


Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Leave a comment