Hyundai Card has put artificial intelligence to the test against its own PR specialists, finding that human judgment and AI efficiency may work better together than either approach alone.
The South Korean credit card company held two internal PR writing contests in March and July under the title “AI vs. PR Specialist: Which Would You Choose?” The exercises compared press releases produced independently by a human communications professional and an AI model.
Employees then assessed the submissions through blind reviews, focusing on factors including strategic narrative, message structure, and logical coherence.
The results were consistent: the human writer won both contests. However, the exercises also showed that AI-generated communications had become difficult to distinguish from professionally written material in several respects.
For Hyundai Card, the experiment has led to a broader conclusion: AI may be most valuable in communications when it works alongside human expertise rather than attempting to replace it.
Hyundai Card Puts AI and PR Specialists Head-to-Head
The first contest took place in March and focused on the Orange, one of Hyundai Card’s premium credit cards.
A former journalist who had joined Hyundai Card’s PR team independently researched and developed the press release. Meanwhile, an AI model created its own version using publicly available information.
The human writer conducted internal reporting to understand the product’s strategic rationale and identify the central messages that Hyundai Card wanted to communicate.
The AI approach was different. It aggregated a broad range of publicly available information before constructing its draft.
Employees evaluated both versions without knowing which had been written by the human or AI.
The human-produced release ultimately won. However, reviewers said the difference between the two became increasingly difficult to identify as they read the submissions.
That result highlighted one of the central challenges facing communications teams adopting generative AI: AI can already produce credible corporate content, even when it may lack the internal context available to employees.
The Second Test Revealed Different Strengths
Hyundai Card repeated the experiment in July.
This time, the task was to create an international-media pitch around Alphabet Card, the company’s newly launched independent brand.
Again, a PR specialist and AI model worked independently before employees conducted a blind evaluation.
The human writer won the second contest as well. Yet reviewers identified clearer differences between the strengths of each approach.
The human-written version was praised for naturally reflecting Hyundai Card’s distinctive corporate voice and vocabulary.
The AI-generated version received recognition for a different quality: it was concise, readable and largely free of unnecessary material.
The findings suggest that the strengths of the two approaches are complementary.
Human communicators can provide institutional knowledge, strategic judgment and brand context. AI, meanwhile, can help organise information and produce structured drafts quickly.
Why Human Context Still Matters in Financial PR
The experiment is particularly relevant to financial-services communications.
Banking and payments companies often need to communicate products that involve complex financial concepts, regulatory considerations, and carefully defined brand positioning.
A press release is therefore not simply a collection of facts.
The writer must determine which facts matter, how they should be connected, and what the announcement means for its intended audience.
That requires context.
Hyundai Card’s experiment suggests that this remains an area where human communicators have an advantage. Internal reporting can uncover information that may not be available publicly, while experienced PR specialists understand the organization’s language, strategic priorities, and audience.
AI can process large amounts of information, but the final editorial judgment still needs to come from somewhere.
AI Could Make PR Teams More Efficient
At the same time, Hyundai Card’s findings demonstrate why communications teams are adopting generative AI so quickly.
AI can significantly reduce the time required for research, drafting, and initial content development.
Rather than starting every announcement with a blank page, communications professionals can use AI to create an initial structure, identify potential messaging angles, or organize background information.
That can leave human writers with more time for higher-value work, including interviews, internal reporting, fact-checking and strategic editing.
Hyundai Card says this is already becoming part of its day-to-day workflow.
For an in-house promotional video, for example, AI was initially used to develop the narrative framework. Human communicators then added context and refined the key messages before completing the final production.
The approach effectively changes AI’s role from content replacement to collaborative production.
Hyundai Card Expands Its AI Communications Strategy
Following the two contests, Hyundai Card plans to expand AI use across a wider range of communications activities.
Potential applications include domestic and international press releases as well as scripts for YouTube videos.
The company does not appear to be positioning AI as an autonomous replacement for its communications employees. Instead, it wants AI to operate as a partner that can strengthen creativity and strategic planning.
That distinction could become increasingly important as financial institutions integrate generative AI into corporate functions.
The question is no longer simply whether AI can write.
It can.
The more important question is where AI should write, where humans should intervene and how the two can work together without weakening accuracy, brand identity or strategic communication.
A Hybrid Model for Financial Communications
Hyundai Card’s experiment offers a practical model for other financial-services companies exploring generative AI.
AI can provide speed, research support and concise first drafts. Human professionals can then supply the institutional knowledge, strategic narrative, brand voice and judgment required to turn that material into finished communications.
The result may be more effective than either approach operating independently.
The company’s experience also challenges the idea that AI adoption must be an all-or-nothing decision.
Instead, financial institutions can identify the parts of the communications process where AI performs well and combine those capabilities with areas where human expertise remains critical.
For Hyundai Card, the two contests were ultimately less about declaring a winner than understanding the capabilities of both.
The bigger lesson for financial communications may be simple: AI does not necessarily have to replace the PR professional to transform PR. It may be more valuable as the tool that allows human communicators to spend less time drafting and more time thinking.


Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Leave a comment