If you’ve decided to pay your tax bill by card, you don’t actually get to choose your payment provider the way you would for a normal purchase, the IRS routes every card transaction through one of exactly two authorized processors. This guide compares them head-to-head so you pick the cheaper one for your specific card type instead of guessing.

The IRS authorizes only two third-party payment processors for card payments: Pay1040 and ACI Payments, Inc. Neither is universally cheaper, ACI edges out debit card payments by a few cents, while Pay1040 is slightly cheaper on both personal and commercial credit cards. On a large payment, that difference adds up to real money, so it’s worth checking both fee schedules before you pay rather than defaulting to whichever one you used last year.

Why the IRS Only Uses Two Processors

Federal law prevents the IRS from directly accepting card payments or absorbing the processing cost itself, so it authorizes a small number of third-party companies to handle the transaction and charge their own convenience fee instead. The list has actually shrunk in recent years, a third processor, PayUSAtax, dropped off the IRS’s list, leaving Pay1040 and ACI Payments, Inc. as the only two options in 2026.

That narrower field is actually good news for comparison shopping: instead of researching a dozen payment solution providers, you only need to compare two.

Pay1040 vs. ACI Payments, Inc.: Fee Comparison

Payment Type Pay1040 ACI Payments, Inc.
Personal/consumer debit card $2.15 flat fee $2.10 flat fee
Personal credit card 1.75% (min $2.50) 1.85% (min $2.50)
Commercial/corporate credit or debit card 2.89% (min $2.50) 2.95% (min $2.50)
Cash payment (via VanillaDirect) $1.50 $1.50
Digital wallets PayPal, Click to Pay PayPal, Click to Pay, Venmo

What This Actually Costs at Different Payment Amounts

Percentage-based fees scale with your balance, so the dollar gap between processors grows on larger payments. Here’s what a personal credit card payment looks like at a few common amounts:

Payment Amount Pay1040 (1.75%) ACI (1.85%)
$1,000 $17.50 $18.50
$2,500 $43.75 $46.25
$10,000 $175.00 $185.00

 

At $10,000, that’s a $10 difference for the exact same payment, small individually, but worth checking every time, especially on commercial cards where the base rate is already higher.

Choosing a Processor by Card Type

If You’re Paying With a Personal Debit Card

ACI Payments: is marginally cheaper at $2.10 flat versus Pay1040’s $2.15, a trivial difference on any single payment, but ACI is the technically better choice here.

If You’re Paying With a Personal Credit Card

Pay1040: wins at 1.75% versus ACI’s 1.85%. On a meaningful tax bill, this is the comparison most worth doing the math on.

If You’re Paying With a Commercial or Corporate Card

Pay1040: is again slightly cheaper at 2.89% versus ACI’s 2.95%. Both minimums are $2.50, so this only matters once your payment is large enough for the percentage to exceed that floor.

If You Want to Use a Digital Wallet

ACI supports one more option, Venmo, in addition to PayPal and Click to Pay, which both processors accept. If your business already routes payments through Venmo for other purposes, that’s a point in ACI’s favor regardless of the flat fee difference.

Is Paying the IRS by Card Actually Worth the Fee?

The math only works in specific situations, running it before you pay saves you from a fee that outweighs any benefit.

  • Chasing a credit card signup bonus: If a new card requires $4,000 in spend for a $750 bonus, a tax payment can get you there fast, even a ~1.75%-2.95% fee is a small price against that kind of return.
  • Using a 0% intro APR card: Paying a large tax bill on a card with a 15-month 0% intro period effectively turns your IRS payment into an interest-free loan, which can be worth far more than the convenience fee.
  • Chasing ordinary cash-back rewards: This rarely pencils out. A 2% cash-back card against a 1.75%-2.95% fee nets you a small profit at best on personal cards, and a real loss on commercial cards, the fee usually exceeds the reward.

If none of those apply to your situation, a free ACH-based option like EFTPS is almost always the better payment solution.

What Neither Processor Can Do

Both Pay1040 and ACI Payments are strictly for tax payments to the IRS, they’re not a substitute for your business’s actual merchant payment processing setup, and there are some payments they simply can’t handle:

  • Employer federal payroll tax deposits: aren’t payable by card through either processor – EFTPS is required.
  • Neither processor sends any portion of the fee to the IRS: The entire convenience fee is processor revenue, separate from your tax payment itself.
  • Fee schedules differ if you pay through e-file software: rather than going directly to pay1040.com or fed.acipayonline.com, so compare both paths before assuming they’re identical.

Making the Decision

  • Paying by personal debit card: ACI Payments, by a few cents.
  • Paying by personal credit card: Pay1040, by about 0.10 percentage points.
  • Paying by commercial or corporate card: Pay1040, by about 0.06 percentage points.
  • Want Venmo as a payment option: ACI Payments is the only one that supports it.
  • Payment is large enough that the percentage difference matters: run both fee schedules against your exact card type and amount before submitting, don’t assume last year’s cheaper option is still cheaper.

FAQ

Are Pay1040 and ACI Payments the only ways to pay the IRS by card?
Yes, as of 2026. A third processor, PayUSAtax, is no longer on the IRS’s authorized list, leaving these two as the only card payment options.

Does the IRS get any part of the card processing fee?
No. The entire convenience fee goes to the processor, Pay1040 or ACI Payments, not to the IRS. Your tax payment amount and the fee are itemized separately on your statement.

Which processor is cheapest for a large business tax payment?
It depends on card type. Pay1040 is generally cheaper for both personal and commercial credit cards, while ACI Payments is marginally cheaper for debit cards. Always compare both for your exact amount.

Can I pay through Pay1040 or ACI Payments using Venmo?
Only ACI Payments currently supports Venmo. Both processors accept PayPal and Click to Pay.

Is the card processing fee tax-deductible?
For business tax payments, generally yes, it’s treated as an ordinary and necessary business expense. Convenience fees on personal income tax payments are not deductible.

Do these processors handle payroll tax deposits?
No. Employer federal tax deposits must be paid through EFTPS; neither Pay1040 nor ACI Payments supports card payment for this tax type.