TL;DR:
Two UK regulators tightened payments rules in 2026. The FCA’s safeguarding regime (live since 7 May) makes firms prove daily, not annually, that customer funds are safe. The PSR’s fraud reimbursement scheme splits scam losses 50/50 between sending and receiving firms. Neither targets merchants directly, but both flow into pricing, onboarding, and risk appetite at every payment provider. Pick one that’s kept up.
Two regulators are pulling UK fintech the same direction this year, and most merchants haven’t noticed: prove your payment provider is actually keeping up, not just licensed.
The Regulatory Background, Verified
The FCA’s safeguarding overhaul: Payment and e-money firms have had to segregate customer funds from their own money since the Payment Services Regulations 2017 and Electronic Money Regulations 2011. What changed is how firms must prove it. Following Policy Statement PS25/12 (and the related PS25/21 update to its Approach Document), the FCA’s new Supplementary Regime, housed in a new CASS 15 sourcebook chapter, took effect on 7 May 2026. It requires daily reconciliation of safeguarded funds, monthly regulatory returns, more prescriptive wording in the acknowledgement letters firms get from the banks holding safeguarded money, and immediate notification to the FCA if reconciliation breaks down. The FCA did build in proportionality: firms safeguarding less than £100,000 in customer funds over the prior year are exempt from the external audit requirement, and the implementation window was extended from six to nine months after industry pushback. A further “Post-Repeal” stage, which would move to a full CASS-style statutory trust model, has been paused pending review of how the current regime performs.
The PSR’s fraud reimbursement regime: Since 7 October 2024, the Payment Systems Regulator has required payment service providers to reimburse victims of authorised push payment (APP) fraud sent over Faster Payments or CHAPS, up to a cap of £85,000 per claim, with the cost split 50/50 between the sending and receiving institution. Firms have five business days to reimburse (35 with an active investigation), and can apply a £100 excess except for vulnerable customers. On 1 July 2026, the PSR published an independent report finding the policy had cut APP fraud losses sent over Faster Payments by roughly 21% in its first year, a genuine consumer-protection win, while confirming a formal consultation on further changes is planned for December 2026.
Both of these are settled, in-force rules, not proposals, worth stating plainly, since a lot of merchant-facing commentary still treats them as upcoming rather than live.
The Core Argument: Compliance-First vs. Leaner Providers, and What Each Trade-off Costs
1. Safeguarding compliance now separates providers by operational maturity, not just by license type
Before May 2026, a merchant evaluating payment providers could reasonably treat “FCA-authorised” as a single quality bar. That’s no longer quite true. The new CASS 15 requirements, daily reconciliation, resolution packs, third-party due diligence on the banks holding safeguarded funds, are administratively demanding enough that smaller payment processing firms are visibly triaging: some have invested early in reconciliation infrastructure and audit relationships, while others are treating 7 May as a deadline to scramble toward rather than a floor they’d already cleared. Merchants can’t always see this from the outside, but it’s a fair, direct question to ask any provider handling merchant funds: has your safeguarding regime already been through an external audit under the new rules, or are you still building toward one?
2. Fraud liability has shifted from a bank-only problem to a two-sided one
The PSR’s 50/50 sending/receiving split is the most underappreciated change for merchants operating payment wallets, marketplaces, or any service where customers can push funds to another account holder on the platform. A merchant that receives payments and unknowingly banks a fraudster’s proceeds is now financially exposed to reimbursement claims, not just the sending bank. That has pushed serious payment providers to tighten receiving-side fraud monitoring, which is a genuine improvement for the ecosystem, the PSR’s own data backs that up, but it also means merchants on lighter-touch platforms may be inheriting fraud-liability exposure they didn’t have two years ago, without necessarily realizing it.
3. Authorisation tier still matters, and it maps onto risk appetite
The UK’s authorisation structure hasn’t changed: firms register as either a full Authorised Payment Institution (API) or a Small Payment Institution (capped at roughly €3 million in average monthly transaction volume), and either a full Authorised EMI or a Small EMI (capped at roughly €5 million in average outstanding e-money). Small institutions face a lighter compliance burden but also lighter regulatory scrutiny and, in some cases, thinner capital requirements, a trade-off that was always true but matters more now that the operational bar for safeguarding compliance has risen sharply for everyone. A Small PI processing online payments for a niche vertical may be a perfectly legitimate, well-run business; it’s also one where a merchant should ask more questions about safeguarding readiness, precisely because the audit exemption threshold (£100,000 in safeguarded funds) may mean no external safeguarding audit has ever happened at all.
4. Cross-border and high-risk verticals feel this first
Merchants running cross-border payments or operating in categories that already need a high-risk payment gateway, gaming, subscription billing, digital goods, are disproportionately exposed to both changes, because they tend to work with smaller, specialist merchant services providers rather than tier-one banks. Those specialists are exactly the firms most likely to be resource-constrained heading into the May 2026 deadline, and exactly the firms whose customer base includes the receiving-side fraud exposure the PSR’s rules were built to address. This isn’t a claim that any specific high-risk provider is non-compliant, that would need firm-by-firm verification, but it is a structural reason high-risk-adjacent merchants should treat 2026 due diligence more seriously than merchants in lower-risk categories.
The Counterpoint
The steelman case against reading too much into any of this: UK digital payments regulation has always had teeth, and firms have always adapted. FCA-authorised status already requires ongoing supervision, capital adequacy, and safeguarding obligations that predate this year’s changes by close to a decade. The PSR’s own data, a 21% drop in APP fraud losses in the reimbursement scheme’s first year, suggests the system is working roughly as intended, without the mass market exit or innovation chill that critics warned about when the rules were proposed. A merchant could reasonably conclude that 2026 is incremental tightening, not a structural break, and that treating it as a major due-diligence trigger is overcorrecting.
That’s a fair read of the aggregate data. But aggregate compliance and individual-firm compliance are different questions, and the aggregate number doesn’t tell a merchant whether their specific provider has cleared the May 2026 bar. The FCA introduced these rules specifically because it found “persistent weaknesses”, poor record-keeping, inadequate reconciliation, delayed fund returns, concentrated among smaller and mid-sized firms, which is exactly the segment many high-risk and niche merchants rely on. The market-wide trend line being positive doesn’t mean every firm in it is compliant; it means the merchants most exposed to a laggard provider are the ones who most need to check rather than assume.
Comparison Table: UK Payment Authorisation Tiers at a Glance
| Dimension | Small Payment Institution (Small PI) | Authorised Payment Institution (API) | Small EMI | Authorised EMI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regulator | FCA | FCA | FCA | FCA |
| Volume/issuance threshold | Avg. monthly payment volume under ~€3m | No upper volume cap | Avg. outstanding e-money under ~€5m | No upper cap |
| Safeguarding audit exemption | Possible if under £100,000 safeguarded funds threshold | Typically required (subject to the £100,000 threshold) | Possible if under £100,000 threshold | Typically required |
| Passporting / cross-border scope | UK-only, more limited | Broader UK and (historically) EEA-linked activity, subject to post-Brexit arrangements | UK-only, more limited | Broader scope |
| Typical merchant fit | Niche, lower-volume merchant services | Larger-scale payment processing | Smaller-scale payment wallets / e-money issuance | Full-scale e-money and payment gateway operations |
| CASS 15 exposure (2026) | Applies, but audit exemption more likely to be available | Applies in full for most firms | Applies, exemption more likely available | Applies in full for most firms |
Practical Takeaway for Merchants
Treat 7 May 2026 as a genuine due-diligence checkpoint, not background noise. When evaluating a payment provider for merchant accounts, payment processing, or a high-risk payment gateway relationship, ask directly: which authorisation tier are they operating under, have they completed (or are they exempt from) an external safeguarding audit under the new CASS 15 rules, and how are they handling receiving-side fraud monitoring given the PSR’s shared-liability model. None of these questions require legal expertise to ask, they require the provider to give a straight, specific answer rather than a general compliance-marketing statement. A provider that can’t answer clearly is telling you something about their operational maturity, regardless of what tier their license technically sits in.
Open question for merchants and fintech watchers: with the FCA’s “Post-Repeal” statutory trust model paused and the PSR heading into a formal consultation this December, is UK payments regulation heading toward a genuinely more resilient, bank-like safeguarding standard for the whole industry, or toward a two-tier market where a shrinking group of well-capitalized firms absorb the compliance cost and everyone else competes on being just under the audit threshold? We’d like to hear from providers and merchants who’ve been through the May 2026 transition directly.


Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Leave a comment